Skip to content
Campus Alert Archive
Colgate

Two Freshmen, One Cessna, Seven Miles Short: Colgate's 2015 Fatal Crash

NYotheradvisorymedium confidence
Confirmed Threat

On September 20, 2015, two Colgate University freshmen -- Cathryn 'Carey' Depuy and Ryan Adams, both 19 and from Connecticut -- died when their Cessna 150 crashed near Morrisville, New York, approximately seven miles from Hamilton Municipal Airport where they had taken off. Depuy, the student pilot, had not yet received her solo endorsement and should not have carried a passenger under FAA rules. Colgate University made counselors available to students and mourned the loss of two freshman members of the Class of 2019.

Alerts
2
Response
Killed
2
Injured
0
Institution
Colgate University
Private Liberal Arts · NY
~3,000 students
Confirmed Timeline

Alert Sequence

2 messages in sequence

Some alert texts below are approximate reconstructions from news coverage, not confirmed verbatim transcripts. Reconstructed texts are shown in italic with a dashed border. Verified verbatim texts have a solid border and are marked accordingly.

INITIAL ALERTEmail
Approximate reconstruction537 chars
Dear Members of the Colgate University Community: We are writing with the heartbreaking news that two first-year students were killed in a small plane crash this afternoon near Hamilton. Cathryn Depuy and Ryan Adams, both members of the Class of 2019, were on board a Cessna that went down near Morrisville. We extend our deepest sympathy to their families, friends, and classmates. Counseling support is available at the chapel beginning this evening. We ask the community to come together to support one another in this difficult time.

This text has been reconstructed from news coverage and may not reflect the exact original wording.

Reconstructed based on multiple news accounts confirming Colgate made counselors available 'two days after the crash,' though the initial notification likely went out the evening of September 20; the university confirmed the identities of both students in its communications
The crash occurred on a Sunday afternoon in late September 2015; the aircraft took off from Hamilton Municipal Airport, which is approximately 3 miles from the Colgate campus; the crash site was about 7 miles from the airport in the town of Eaton
Colgate had approximately 3,000 students in 2015; the loss of two freshmen in the first weeks of the academic year had immediate impact on the first-year cohort and residence hall communities
FOLLOW-UPEmail
Approximate reconstruction521 chars
This is a follow-up message from Colgate University regarding the tragic loss of Carey Depuy and Ryan Adams. Grief counseling continues to be available at the university chapel. The FAA and National Transportation Safety Board are investigating the circumstances of the crash. We encourage all members of the community, particularly first-year students, to seek support if they are struggling. Memorial information will be shared as it becomes available. Our community holds Carey, Ryan, and their families in our hearts.

This text has been reconstructed from news coverage and may not reflect the exact original wording.

News accounts specify that counselors were made available 'two days after the crash,' meaning September 22, 2015; this reconstructed follow-up reflects the documented institutional response timeline
The FAA determined that Depuy had a student pilot license obtained in October 2013 but had not yet received the solo endorsement required before carrying a passenger -- a violation of FAA rules that will feature in the NTSB investigation
The crash site was in the town of Eaton, Madison County, New York, approximately 7 miles southeast of the Hamilton Municipal Airport from which they departed
Context

Background

On September 20, 2015, two Colgate University freshmen, Cathryn 'Carey' Depuy and Ryan Adams, both 19 years old and from Connecticut, were killed when their Cessna 150 crashed in the town of Eaton, New York, approximately seven miles from Hamilton Municipal Airport. Depuy had taken off from Hamilton -- the airport closest to the Colgate campus -- on a Sunday afternoon. She had obtained her student pilot license in October 2013, but the FAA determined she had not yet received a solo endorsement, which was required before she could carry a passenger. Adams was therefore an unauthorized passenger under federal aviation rules. Both students were members of the Class of 2019, only weeks into their first semester at Colgate. The University confirmed the loss and directed students to grief counseling at the chapel. The FAA and NTSB opened investigations. The crash raised questions about the supervision of student pilots who hold early-stage certificates but have not yet met the threshold for carrying passengers. Hamilton Municipal Airport is a general-aviation field about 3 miles from the Colgate campus that is used frequently by students and local pilots; its proximity to the campus means small-aircraft accidents in the area may involve community members.
Analysis

Key Findings

Two Colgate University freshmen (both 19, from Connecticut) killed when their Cessna 150 crashed near Morrisville, NY, 7 miles from Hamilton Municipal Airport on September 20, 2015
Student pilot Cathryn 'Carey' Depuy had not yet received her FAA solo endorsement permitting her to carry a passenger -- a violation of federal aviation rules identified in the FAA/NTSB investigation
Colgate's response was bereavement-focused: counselors at the chapel, community notifications; the crash occurred off-campus and posed no ongoing campus safety threat
The loss of two members of the first-year Class of 2019 in the opening weeks of the semester had acute impact on the small liberal-arts campus community of approximately 3,000 students
All alert text is reconstructed (isVerbatimConfirmed: false); no verbatim Colgate notification emails were recoverable
Outcome
Both students killed. Cathryn 'Carey' Depuy (student pilot, 19, from Connecticut) and Ryan Adams (19, Connecticut) died in the crash. FAA and NTSB investigated. Depuy had received her student pilot license in October 2013 but had not yet received a solo endorsement permitting her to fly with a passenger. Colgate made counselors available at the chapel.
Provenance

Sources

  1. News
  2. News
  3. News
  4. News
Tags
aviationplane-crashstudent-pilotnew-yorkfreshmanstudent-deathfaa-violationliberal-artssmall-campusbereavement-notification
Added May 2026Updated May 2026Via ingestion